Imagine spending time setting up a WooCommerce Wishlist plugin, only to realize it doesn’t work well with your theme or other plugins. Now, think about this: your theme or one of your plugins gets an update, and suddenly your wishlist stops working or crashes, affecting how your website looks.
But there’s more at stake. If you pick the wrong wishlist, you might miss out on potential customers and struggle to build their loyalty and positive word of mouth. Just installing the YITH WooCommerce Wishlist plugin without considering these things might not give you the results you want. And if you make the wrong choices during setup, it could lead to problems.
In this article, I’ll review 18 wishlist plugins, helping you find the best one for your WooCommerce store. Make a smart decision and save time and money—keep reading to find the perfect plugin for you!
Why consider an alternative to YITH WooCommerce Wishlist?
The YITH WooCommerce Wishlist started in May 2013 when there weren’t many plugins around. Being one of the first gave it an advantage, and now it’s widely used, often installed automatically by hostings and popular themes.
If you’re thinking about going with YITH just because many people have it, that’s only part of the story. Being around early doesn’t guarantee it’s the best.
However, YITH Wishlist hasn’t kept up with updates and features users ask for. Over the years, improvements have been minimal, mostly focusing on working with WordPress and WooCommerce. This might mean they’re not as motivated to bring in new ideas.
Look at the picture below to see how few updates there have been, possibly to keep users interested.
Now, YITH has fully transitioned to Newfold Digital, as per a recent Crunchbase report. Usually, when a company changes hands, it shifts focus to things like changing prices, new marketing plans, and making more sales.
As you can see in the image below, solving problems isn’t a top priority, suggesting a change in focus.
Wondering if there’s a better choice? Keep reading as we explore other options. Your WooCommerce store deserves the best.
Choose Best Woocommerce Wishlist Plugin – List of all plugins
Below, we’ve curated a comprehensive list of 18 WooCommerce Wishlist plugins available in WordPress, sparing you the need for extensive searching.
We will meticulously filter through each of these plugins and examine them closely to provide you with the best alternatives for choosing a suitable WooCommerce Wishlist plugin for your store by the end of this article.
- TI WooCommerce Wishlist – TemplateInvaders – 100,000+
- MoreConvert WooCommerce Wishlist – MoreConvert – 2,000+
- Addonify – WooCommerce Wishlist – Addonify – 1,000+
- Flexible Wishlist for WooCommerce – Ecommerce Wishlist & Save for later – WP Desk – 800+
- Premerce Wishlist for WooCommerce – Premerce – 400+
- Booster for WooCommerce – Pluggable LLC – 60,000+
- WPC Smart Wishlist for WooCommerce – WPClever – 70,000+
- Wishlist – PickPlugins – 600+
- Wishlist for WooCommerce – WebToffee – 500+
- Wishlist for WooCommerce – WPInteractive – 1,000+
- LearnPress – Course Wishlist – ThimPress – 20,000+
- Wishlist and Save for later for Woocommerce – Acowebs – 100+
- Wishlist for WooCommerce – WPFactory – 2,000+
- Wishlist and Compare for WooCommerce – ThemeHigh – 100+
- WishSuite – Wishlist for WooCommerce – HasTheme – 1,000+
- WCBoost – Wishlist – WCBoost – 10,000+
- NM Gift Registry and Wishlist Lite – Nmeri Media – 300
- ProductX – WooCommerce Builder & Gutenberg WooCommerce Blocks – wpxpo – 3,000+
Only those meeting minimum criteria progress to the next level of consideration. This process encompasses evaluating customer satisfaction, core wishlist features, and advanced functionalities.
Customer Satisfaction Comparison
In this section, we delve into customer satisfaction by evaluating plugins based on their update frequency and user ratings. We exclude plugins that don’t meet these criteria for a fair comparison with the YITH WooCommerce Wishlist Plugin.
| Name | Real-Updates | Ratings (5) | Active-Installs | Price | Refund | Simplicity | Demo | Overall-Score |
| TI WooCommerce Wishlist | Monthly | 4.5 | 100,000+ | Free $79 – $499 | 14-Day | Simple | ✅ | 90 |
| YITH WooCommerce Wishlist | Monthly | 4 | 900,000+ | Free $99 | 30-Day | Moderate | ✅ | 90 |
| MoreConvert WooCommerce Wishlist | Bi-Weekly | 5 | 2,000+ | Free $79 – $499 | 14-Day | Simple | ✅ | 90 |
| Addonify | Occasional | 5 | 1,000+ | Free | 7-Day | Simple | ✅ | 85 |
| Flexible Wishlist for WooCommerce | Occasional | 4.5 | 900+ | $59 – $199 | 30-Day | Moderate | ✅ | 65 |
| Premerce Wishlist for WooCommerce | Rare | 3.5 | 400+ | Free | 30-Day | Simple | ✅ | 45 |
| Booster for WooCommerce | Monthly | 4.5 | 50,000+ | Free $11.99 – $24.99 | 30-Day | Complex | ❌ | 45 |
| WPC Smart Wishlist for WooCommerce | Monthly | 4.9 | 70,000+ | Free $33 – $111 | 7-Day | Simple | ✅ | 80 |
| Wishlist by PickPlugins | Monthly | 3.5 | 600+ | Free $19 – $199 | 7-Day | Simple | ✅ | 75 |
| Wishlist for WooCommerce | Monthly | 4 | 1,000+ | Free | 30-Day | Simple | ❌ | 65 |
| Wishlist for WooCommerce | Occasional | 4.5 | 400+ | Free | N/A | Complex | ❌ | 70 |
| LearnPress | Occasional | 3 | 20,000+ | Free | – | Moderate | ❌ | 50 |
| Wishlist and Save for later for Woocommerce | Occasional | 4.5 | 90+ | Free $39 – $179 | 30-Day | Simple | ✅ | 75 |
| Wishlist for WooCommerce | Bi-Weekly | 4.9 | 2,000+ | Free $4.17 – 29.92 | 14-Day | Simple | ❌ | 85 |
| Wishlist and Compare for WooCommerce | Occasional | 4.5 | 200+ | Free | – | Simple | ❌ | 75 |
| WishSuite | Occasional | 5 | 1,000+ | Free | – | Simple | ❌ | 80 |
| WCBoost – Wishlist | Occasional | N/A | 10,000+ | Free | – | Simple | ❌ | 60 |
| NM Gift Registry and Wishlist Lite | Monthly | 4.9 | 200+ | Free $99 | N/A | Simple | ❌ | 80 |
| ProductX | Bi-Weekly | 4.9 | 4,000+ | Free $44 – $873 | 14-Day | Complex | ✅ | 50 |
Legend
The criteria we have placed in this comparative table are as follows:
- Real Update: Updates with bug fixes, feature additions, or integrations.
- Ratings: High ratings are marked as 5/5.
- Active Install: Number of active installations of the plugin across WordPress websites. This metric gives insight into the popularity and adoption of the plugin among users.
- Price: This column considers whether the plugin is free or paid, and evaluates the value proposition offered in relation to its features.
- Refund: Assesses availability of a refund option for dissatisfied users or those experiencing functionality issues.
- Simplicity: Evaluates plugin ease of use, navigation, and user-friendliness, with emphasis on clear documentation and support.
- Demo: Availability of a live demo.
- Overall Score: At last, using the factors mentioned earlier, we give each plugin a total score from 100.
Top Picked Aspects
Here, we have also selected plugins that excel in the mentioned features compared to other plugins.
- MoreConvert WooCommerce Wishlist: Offers the most interactive demo along with comprehensive documentation for a seamless user experience.
- TI WooCommerce Wishlist: Stands out with its highest reviews and the most reviewers, reflecting its exceptional trustworthiness and popularity among users.
- Wishlist (By PickPlugins): Offers the most simple and minimal options for streamlined functionality.
- Addonify – WooCommerce Wishlist and “WishSuite”: Stand out for being completely free among WooCommerce wishlist plugins.
Winner
And finally, based on the reviews and comparisons conducted in this filter, we have selected the winners of this stage in a visual representation on the chart below, based on their scores.
Alongside this comparison, 4 plugins did not pass our filters and were eliminated from the competition. Meanwhile, 14 plugins managed to receive a score above 50 from us.
Core Wishlist Features Comparison
Reviewing plugins with a score above fifty from the Customer Satisfaction Comparison and applying technical filters.
| Name | Easy-Install | Integration | Customizability | Responsiveness | Appearance | Support | Shareability | Overall Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TI WooCommerce Wishlist | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 100 |
| MoreConvert WooCommerce Wishlist | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 100 |
| Addonify | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | 45 |
| Flexible Wishlist for WooCommerce | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | 40 |
| WPC Smart Wishlist for WooCommerce | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | 40 |
| Wishlist by PickPlugins | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | 40 |
| Wishlist for WooCommerce (WebToffee) | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | 30 |
| Wishlist for WooCommerce (WPInteractive) | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | 15 |
| Wishlist and Save for later for Woocommerce | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 70 |
| Wishlist for WooCommerce (WPFactory) | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | 60 |
| Wishlist and Compare for WooCommerce | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | 50 |
| WishSuite | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | 50 |
| WCBoost – Wishlist | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | 45 |
| NM Gift Registry and Wishlist Lite | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | 40 |
Technical table
- Easy setup: Assessing the simplicity and efficiency of the plugin’s installation, initial configuration process, and setup wizard, if applicable.
- Compatibility and Integration with Themes and Plugins: Evaluating how well the plugin integrates with various WordPress themes and other plugins, ensuring seamless functionality.
- Customizability: Examining the extent to which users can customize the plugin’s settings, features, and appearance to align with their specific requirements.
- Responsiveness and User-friendliness: Gauging the responsiveness and user-friendliness of the plugin’s interface and features across different devices and screen sizes.
- Appearance: Reviewing the visual design and aesthetics of the plugin’s interface and wishlist display options.
- Help and Support: Assessing the availability and quality of support resources, documentation, and assistance provided by the plugin developers to users.
- Shareability features: Evaluating the presence and functionality of features that enable users to share their wishlist items easily with others through social media.
Top Picked Aspects
- The MoreConvert WooCommerce Wishlist was the only plugin among its competitors that had no unanswered questions in its support forum. All user issues and inquiries were thoroughly addressed and resolved.
- The TI and MoreConvert plugins offered highly detailed and precise customization options across all sections of the wishlist. This level of customization was not found in any of the other plugins under review, with the rest only providing basic customization options to users.
- Wishlist and Save for later for WooCommerce: While this plugin is not offering extensive customization options, features a simple and minimalistic out-of-the-box appearance.
Winner
After a detailed evaluation of 14 plugins based on key metrics such as Easy-Install, Customizability, Support, and Shareability, only three plugins managed to meet our rigorous standards. The winners, depicted in the chart below, achieved commendable scores:
Advanced Wishlist Features Comparison
Checking plugins with a score of over seventy on Core Wishlist Features Comparison based on advanced options and re-scoring from one hundred.
| Name | Marketing Features | Analytics | Estimate requests | Smart coupons | Email automation | Email campaign | Out of stock | Save For Later | Multi-lists | Move Between Lists | Drag And Drop | Overall Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TI WooCommerce Wishlist | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 80 |
| MoreConvert WooCommerce Wishlist | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 90 |
| Wishlist and Save for later for Woocommerce | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | 50 |
Advanced Filters
- Wishlist Plugin Marketing Features: These are functionalities integrated into the wishlist plugin that enable marketing initiatives. This could include features like social sharing of wishlists, personalized recommendations based on wishlist items, or integration with marketing automation tools.
- Analytics: This feature provides insights and data regarding wishlist usage, including metrics such as the most wished-for products, user engagement with wishlists, conversion rates from wishlists to purchases, and other valuable analytics to inform marketing and product strategies.
- Estimate requests: This feature allows users to request estimates for the items in their wishlist, such as pricing inquiries.
- Smart coupons: These are automated discount offers or incentives triggered based on wishlist activity, such as reaching a certain wishlist value, adding specific products to the wishlist, or sharing the wishlist on social media.
- Email automation: This filter includes features that automates the process of sending targeted emails to users based on their wishlist activity, such as reminders for items left in the wishlist, personalized recommendations, or exclusive offers for wishlist items.
- Email campaign: This refers to the ability to create and execute email marketing campaigns targeted specifically at users who have created wishlists. These campaigns can include promotional offers, product highlights, or reminders to encourage wishlist conversion.
- Out of stock: This feature manages items in the wishlist that become out of stock, providing options for users to receive notifications when the items are back in stock.
- Save for later: Users can temporarily remove items from their cart and store them separately for future consideration or purchase, without deleting them entirely from the cart.
- Multi lists: Users can create and manage multiple wishlists for different purposes or occasions, allowing for better organization and segmentation of desired items.
- Move between lists: This feature enables users to easily transfer items from one wishlist to another, facilitating better organization in managing multiple wishlists.
- Drag and drop: Users can rearrange items within their wishlist using intuitive drag-and-drop functionality, making it easier to prioritize or organize desired products according to preference.
Top Picked Aspects
- MoreConvert WooCommerce Wishlist: The MoreConvert plugin offers a comprehensive set of wishlist features, continually expanding its offerings, particularly in the free version. Its marketing capabilities are particularly noteworthy, even in the free version, making it suitable for smaller stores.
- TI WooCommerce Wishlist: This plugin simplifies wishlist features in a user-friendly manner, eliminating complex configurations. Its essential marketing settings are presented clearly for your convenience.
Winner
While both TI and MoreConvert plugins offer essential features alongside a Wishlist, there’s a distinction in their approach. TI’s essential and marketing features are exclusive to the Pro version, whereas MoreConvert provides many features in the free version. For most WooCommerce store wishlist needs, the free version of MoreConvert suffices.
Hence, our choice as the winner for this category is the MoreConvert WooCommerce Wishlist Plugin.
Overall Comparison for Winner in Yith WooCommerce Wishlist Alternatives
Providing the final table comparing all the features of the winning plugins and scoring out of a hundred. The list should encompass all plugin options.
In our thorough review of WooCommerce Wishlist plugins, we analyzed 18 options against detailed filters and criteria.
We began by evaluating parameters like customer satisfaction, ease of use, pricing, and ratings. Then, we assessed them based on essential “Core Features” for wishlist plugins and explored their professional and marketing capabilities.
Ultimately, MoreConvert Wishlist emerged as the standout choice, meeting our criteria exceptionally well and positioning itself as the top alternative to Yith. 🏆
Best WooCommerce Wishlist Plugin Based on User Role
Presenting different user scenarios (small business owner, affiliate, marketing agency, website designer) and recommending plugins based on their specific needs.
In this segment, we delve into the top WooCommerce Wishlist Plugins tailored to different user roles. We carefully consider the needs of small business owners, affiliates, marketing agencies, and website designers, offering tailored recommendations for each.
Whether you’re managing a small business or working as an affiliate, we offer targeted recommendations to streamline your Wishlist Plugin selection. Similarly, for marketing agencies and website designers, our suggestions cater to your unique needs.
- For small business owners seeking simplicity and essential features, Wishlist and Save for Later for WooCommerce stands out with its straightforward presentation and minimal customizations.
- For marketing agencies, both TI Wishlist and MoreConvert Wishlist are excellent choices, offering robust marketing features that enhance client engagement and conversion rates.
- Website designers would benefit most from MoreConvert Wishlist, which offers an extensive range of features, including many free options, customizable elements, and excellent support services.
Curious about alternatives to the TI WooCommerce Wishlist plugin? Check out our comprehensive article on the subject. We’ve provided an in-depth comparison of various options to help you make the best choice for your needs. Happy exploring!
